Most large companies now tie some executive pay to ESG performance, but the design choice that determines whether it changes behavior is structural: whether the metrics sit in the short-term incentive plan (STIP), the long-term incentive plan (LTIP), or both, and how much weight they carry. Evidence points to a clear pattern. Short-term plans are the more common home for ESG metrics, but incorporating them into LTIPs is considered a leading practice because it aligns with the long-term nature of sustainability goals and the larger share of compensation those plans represent. Weighting matters just as much: around 20% is common, 30% on material issues is considered best-in-class, and weights as low as 2–5% risk being read as greenwashing.
Choosing Your Incentive Horizon: STIP vs. LTIP for ESG Metrics
The first design decision is which plan houses the metric, and it should follow from the nature of the objective. A STIP scorecard, measured on annual performance, suits operational goals a leadership team can move within a year. An LTIP suits transformation goals whose outcomes unfold over multiple years and where the payoff horizon matches the strategy's own horizon.
According to Dominik Legault and Yan Vermeulen, writing for Odgers, incorporating ESG measures into LTIPs is considered a leading practice because it "aligns well with the long-term nature of many ESG metrics and typically constitutes a larger proportion of an executive's compensation package, fostering a stronger commitment to sustainable business practices." That size advantage matters: a metric placed in the plan that carries more of the executive's total pay has more leverage over behavior.
There is also a hybrid path. Some companies link the two plans through front-end performance conditioning, in which annual STIP performance influences the size of LTIP grants. Odgers identifies organizations including major banks, Canadian Natural Resources Limited, and Canadian Apartment Properties REIT as using this approach, which lets annual ESG results modulate long-term rewards without requiring fully quantified multi-year targets.
Adoption, however, is uneven. A Conference Board analysis, discussed by Matteo Tonello on the Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance, notes that limited adoption of ESG metrics in long-term plans reflects challenges in setting credible long-term targets, including data limitations, evolving ESG criteria, and potential misalignment with traditional financial goals. The same analysis suggests integration into long-term plans may increase as companies build ESG data capabilities and respond to expanding mandatory sustainability reporting requirements in the US and internationally.




